Gate first.
Score second.

RuleBreakDeviationFitTarget {
  targetRef,

  targetSourceRef,
  targetSourceOwnerRef,

  valueKind:
    METRIC_MAGNITUDE
    NORMALIZED_MAGNITUDE,

  metricContextRef?,
  metricUnit?,
  normalizationRef?,

  preferredMin,
  preferredMax,

  lowerFalloff,
  upperFalloff,

  hardMin?,
  hardMax?,

  weight,
  required,

  provenance,
  status,
  mutationAllowed: false
}

RuleBreakOverrideScoringProfile {
  overrideScoringProfileRef,

  profileSourceRef,
  profileSourceOwnerRef,

  appliesToIntentModes[],
  appliesToTargetFamilies[],

  deviationTargetRefs[],

  aggregation:
    WEIGHTED_MEAN,

  requireProtectionPass: true,
  requireBudgetPass: true,
  requireJustificationSufficient: true,

  requiredTargetNAHandling:
    N_A,

  optionalTargetNAHandling:
    DROP_EXPLICIT_OPTIONAL_ONLY,

  provenance,
  status,
  mutationAllowed: false
}

MetricResult {
  key,
  owner,
  value,

  applicability,
  confidence,
  status,
  provenance,

  composite,
  componentOf,

  dependsOn[],
  derivedFrom[],

  scoringGroup,
  independentVoteAllowed,

  evidence,
  repairHints[]
}

RuleBreakOverrideEvaluation {
  overrideEvaluationRef,

  candidateRef,
  overrideScoringProfileRef,
  targetSetFingerprint,

  hardGateSynthesisRef,

  componentMetricResults[],
  compositeMetricResult,

  outcome:
    INVALID
    REJECT
    N_A
    KEEP,

  reasonCode,

  confidence,
  provenance,
  derivedFrom[],

  mutationAllowed: false
}

{
  "module": "Compo 12.04",
  "name": "override_scoring_and_tests",
  "version": "1.0-canonical",
  "canonical_main_title": "Override scoring and tests",
  "topic": "12_НАРУШЕНИЕ_СЕТКИ_И_КОНТРОЛИРУЕМОЕ_НАПРЯЖЕНИЕ",
  "scope": "FINAL_LOCAL_TOPIC12_HARD_GATE_SYNTHESIS_EXPLICIT_DEVIATION_TARGET_FIT_SCORING_AND_CONSOLIDATED_TESTS",
  "main_topic_contract": {
    "topic_title": "Нарушение сетки и контролируемое напряжение",
    "topic_goal": "formalize intentional breaking of grid and alignment: deviation magnitude, protected relations, exception budget and justification so controlled tension is distinguishable from error",
    "expected_output": "RuleBreakIntent, deviation metrics, exception budget, evidence",
    "planned_files": [
      "12.00 Grid-break taxonomy and intent",
      "12.01 Deviation magnitude",
      "12.02 Protected relations and exception budgets",
      "12.03 Rule-break candidates and justification",
      "12.04 Override scoring and tests"
    ]
  },
  "ownership": {
    "owner": "Compo12.04",
    "owns": [
      "RuleBreakDeviationFitTarget",
      "RuleBreakOverrideScoringProfile",
      "RuleBreakHardGateSynthesis",
      "per-target deviation fit components",
      "ruleBreak.system.localControlledBreakFit",
      "RuleBreakOverrideEvaluation",
      "same-profile local comparison semantics",
      "Topic12 consolidated local status precedence",
      "Topic12.04 regression contract"
    ],
    "does_not_own": [
      "RuleBreakIntent target/taxonomy/source — Compo12.00",
      "deviation geometry/measurement — Compo12.01",
      "protected relations or exception-budget accounting — Compo12.02",
      "candidate generation or justification evidence — Compo12.03",
      "upstream grid/alignment geometry — Topics8/9/10",
      "global composition quality",
      "global rule/conflict priority",
      "final layout placement",
      "foreign state mutation"
    ]
  },
  "consumes": [
    "valid Compo12.00 RuleBreakTargetEvidence",
    "valid Compo12.00 RuleBreakIntent",
    "valid Compo12.00 RuleBreakIntentResolution",
    "valid Compo12.03 RuleBreakCandidate",
    "valid Compo12.01 RuleBreakDeviationMeasurement",
    "valid Compo12.02 ProtectedRelationGateEvaluation",
    "valid Compo12.02 ExceptionBudgetBundleEvaluation",
    "valid Compo12.03 RuleBreakJustificationEvaluation",
    "valid Compo12.03 RuleBreakCandidateEvidenceBundle",
    "explicit RuleBreakOverrideScoringProfile"
  ],
  "provides": [
    "RuleBreakDeviationFitTarget",
    "RuleBreakOverrideScoringProfile",
    "RuleBreakHardGateSynthesis",
    "MetricResult components ruleBreak.deviationTarget.componentFit.<targetRef>",
    "MetricResult composite ruleBreak.system.localControlledBreakFit",
    "RuleBreakOverrideEvaluation",
    "same-profile diagnostic/local ranking relation",
    "Topic12.04 observation record"
  ],
  "independent_numeric_vote": {
    "key": "ruleBreak.system.localControlledBreakFit",
    "owner": "Compo12.04",
    "composite": true,
    "componentOf": null,
    "scoringGroup": "rule-break-local",
    "independentVoteAllowed": true,
    "meaning": "EXPLICIT_TOPIC12_CONTROLLED_BREAK_TARGET_FIT_ONLY"
  },
  "component_metric": {
    "keyPattern": "ruleBreak.deviationTarget.componentFit.<targetRef>",
    "owner": "Compo12.04",
    "composite": false,
    "componentOf": "ruleBreak.system.localControlledBreakFit",
    "scoringGroup": "rule-break-local",
    "independentVoteAllowed": false
  },
  "deviation_fit_target_schema": {
    "targetRef": "stable identity",
    "targetSourceRef": "explicit source of target band",
    "targetSourceOwnerRef": "owner of band policy",
    "valueKind": "METRIC_MAGNITUDE|NORMALIZED_MAGNITUDE",
    "metricContextRef": "required for METRIC_MAGNITUDE; null otherwise",
    "metricUnit": "required for METRIC_MAGNITUDE; null otherwise",
    "normalizationRef": "required for NORMALIZED_MAGNITUDE; null otherwise",
    "preferredMin": "finite >=0",
    "preferredMax": "finite >= preferredMin",
    "lowerFalloff": "finite >0",
    "upperFalloff": "finite >0",
    "hardMin": "optional finite >=0 and <= preferredMin",
    "hardMax": "optional finite >= preferredMax",
    "weight": "finite >0 explicit local aggregation weight",
    "required": "boolean",
    "provenance": "canonical provenance class",
    "status": "OK|INVALID",
    "mutationAllowed": false
  },
  "fit_formula": {
    "withinPreferredBand": "fit=1",
    "belowPreferredBand": "fit=1-clamp((preferredMin-value)/lowerFalloff,0,1)",
    "abovePreferredBand": "fit=1-clamp((value-preferredMax)/upperFalloff,0,1)",
    "hardMin": "value < hardMin => REJECT, no numeric component for this target",
    "hardMax": "value > hardMax => REJECT, no numeric component for this target",
    "firewall": "hard reject is not numeric zero"
  },
  "scoring_profile_schema": {
    "overrideScoringProfileRef": "stable identity",
    "profileSourceRef": "explicit profile source",
    "profileSourceOwnerRef": "owner of scoring policy",
    "appliesToIntentModes": "non-empty explicit subset of ALLOW_EXCEPTION|EXPLORE_BREAK|REQUEST_BREAK",
    "appliesToTargetFamilies": "non-empty explicit subset of Topic12 target families",
    "deviationTargetRefs": "one or more unique target refs",
    "aggregation": "WEIGHTED_MEAN",
    "requireProtectionPass": true,
    "requireBudgetPass": true,
    "requireJustificationSufficient": true,
    "requiredTargetNAHandling": "N_A",
    "optionalTargetNAHandling": "DROP_EXPLICIT_OPTIONAL_ONLY",
    "provenance": "canonical provenance class",
    "status": "OK|INVALID",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "default": "NONE — no universal ideal deviation band"
  },
  "hard_gate_synthesis": {
    "preconditions": [
      "intent resolution controlledTensionEligible=true",
      "candidate is explicit and lineage-compatible",
      "candidate evidence bundle binds required upstream results"
    ],
    "precedence": [
      "INVALID",
      "REJECT",
      "N_A",
      "KEEP"
    ],
    "invalid": [
      "malformed/incompatible lineage",
      "bundle contradiction",
      "profile/target contract invalid"
    ],
    "reject": [
      "protected relation gate REJECT",
      "exception budget bundle REJECT",
      "justification evaluation INSUFFICIENT when profile requires sufficient justification",
      "explicit hard deviation bound violated"
    ],
    "na": [
      "required upstream gate/evidence unavailable",
      "profile not applicable to explicit intent mode or target family",
      "required deviation target value unavailable"
    ],
    "keep": "all required hard gates pass and all required target values are available"
  },
  "metric_result_contract": {
    "minimumFields": [
      "key",
      "owner",
      "value",
      "applicability",
      "confidence",
      "status",
      "provenance",
      "composite",
      "componentOf",
      "dependsOn",
      "derivedFrom",
      "scoringGroup",
      "independentVoteAllowed",
      "evidence",
      "repairHints"
    ],
    "compositeKey": "ruleBreak.system.localControlledBreakFit",
    "componentPattern": "ruleBreak.deviationTarget.componentFit.<targetRef>",
    "compositeAggregation": "weighted mean of available explicit target components",
    "requiredNA": "any required target N_A => composite N_A unless INVALID/REJECT precedence",
    "optionalNA": "may drop denominator only because optionality is explicit",
    "confidence": "minimum evidence confidence among contributing inputs; never tension strength",
    "provenance": "DERIVED"
  },
  "comparison_policy": {
    "requires": [
      "both evaluations outcome KEEP",
      "same overrideScoringProfileRef",
      "same targetSetFingerprint",
      "same scoringGroup rule-break-local"
    ],
    "relations": [
      "LESS",
      "EQUAL_WITHIN_EPS",
      "GREATER",
      "INCOMPARABLE"
    ],
    "meaning": "EXPLICIT_TOPIC12_CONTROLLED_BREAK_TARGET_FIT_ONLY",
    "firewalls": [
      "comparison is not beauty/global quality",
      "higher localControlledBreakFit is not automatic final-layout winner",
      "cross-profile ranking is forbidden"
    ]
  },
  "status_policy": {
    "evaluationOutcome": "INVALID|REJECT|N_A|KEEP",
    "precedence": "INVALID > REJECT > N_A > KEEP",
    "hardReject": "value=null; no conversion to numeric zero",
    "requiredNA": "value=null; N_A != 0",
    "keep": "numeric composite may be 0..1 inclusive",
    "zeroScore": "legal only as an actual soft fit outcome under KEEP; not a proxy for REJECT or N_A"
  },
  "identity_policy": {
    "targetRef": "hash(source/owner, value kind/context, preferred band, falloffs, hard bounds, weight, required, provenance)",
    "overrideScoringProfileRef": "hash(profile source/owner, canonical intent modes, target families, canonical target refs, fixed aggregation/gate policies)",
    "targetSetFingerprint": "hash(canonical target refs and target identities)",
    "hardGateSynthesisRef": "hash(candidate/upstream gate refs and categorical decisions)",
    "overrideEvaluationRef": "hash(candidateRef, profileRef, targetSetFingerprint, hardGateSynthesisRef, component metric refs, composite result status/value)",
    "set_semantics": "set-like refs are canonicalized",
    "excluded_from_identity": [
      "display label",
      "display color",
      "free-form comment",
      "confidence"
    ]
  },
  "critical_firewalls": [
    "RuleBreakIntent != override permission",
    "candidate != placement",
    "deviation magnitude != score",
    "larger deviation != better",
    "smaller deviation != safer by default",
    "preferred band must be explicit; no universal ideal tension",
    "hard protection REJECT != score 0",
    "budget REJECT != score 0",
    "justification INSUFFICIENT != score 0",
    "required N_A != score 0",
    "optional N_A may drop denominator only when optionality is explicit",
    "protection PASS != score 1",
    "budget PASS != score 1",
    "justification SUFFICIENT != score 1",
    "evidence confidence != fit",
    "candidate ordinal != rank",
    "candidate count != vote",
    "target count != vote",
    "explicit target weight != global rule priority",
    "family identity != hidden weight",
    "REQUEST_BREAK != priority",
    "module execution order != rule priority",
    "localControlledBreakFit != global composition quality",
    "localControlledBreakFit != beautyScore",
    "only one independent Topic12 numeric vote",
    "component metrics cannot vote independently",
    "correction request != foreign mutation",
    "N_A != 0",
    "IDEA != CANON",
    "EXPERIMENT != CANON"
  ],
  "IDEAS_REFS": [
    "IDEA-01 full human test after all 72 topics; validate controlled-tension fit bands empirically",
    "IDEA-02 semantics required before placement; semantic refs remain external to 12.04 scoring",
    "IDEA-03 explicit rule priorities; local target weights and module order must not become global priority",
    "IDEA-04 collect structured data for future composition model",
    "IDEA-05 preserve reasons for human corrections",
    "IDEA-06 structured machine-readable layer",
    "IDEA-07 graphics-for-post-text research remains downstream/separate"
  ],
  "DATA_CAPTURE": [
    "sceneRef",
    "candidateRef",
    "overrideScoringProfileRef",
    "targetSetFingerprint",
    "hardGateSynthesisRef",
    "protectionGateDecision",
    "budgetBundleDecision",
    "justificationDecision",
    "deviationMeasurementRef",
    "targetRefs[]",
    "componentMetricKeys[]",
    "componentValues[]",
    "compositeMetricKey",
    "compositeValue",
    "evaluationOutcome",
    "evaluationReasonCode",
    "humanReasonCodes[]"
  ],
  "DEFERRED_SEMANTIC_INPUTS": [
    "semanticIntentRefs[]",
    "perceptual meaning of preferred band",
    "role-specific controlled-tension tolerance",
    "brand/editorial rationale interpretation",
    "future global conflict-priority policy refs"
  ],
  "HUMAN_FEEDBACK_HOOKS": [
    "CONTROLLED_BREAK_FIT_TOO_HIGH",
    "CONTROLLED_BREAK_FIT_TOO_LOW",
    "PREFERRED_DEVIATION_BAND_WRONG",
    "HARD_DEVIATION_BOUND_WRONG",
    "TARGET_WEIGHT_WRONG",
    "REQUIRED_TARGET_SHOULD_BE_OPTIONAL",
    "OPTIONAL_TARGET_SHOULD_BE_REQUIRED",
    "HARD_GATE_DECISION_WRONG",
    "BREAK_READS_ACCIDENTAL",
    "BREAK_READS_INTENTIONAL_BUT_WEAK",
    "BREAK_READS_OVERDONE",
    "TENSION_READS_AS_ERROR"
  ],
  "CONFLICT_PRIORITY_ASSUMPTIONS": [
    "module execution order is not priority",
    "hard-gate precedence is local Topic12 evaluation semantics, not universal COMPO priority",
    "profile target weights aggregate only within rule-break-local scoring group",
    "REQUEST_BREAK has no priority bonus",
    "higher localControlledBreakFit cannot override a foreign hard constraint",
    "future reviewed global conflict-priority owner remains authoritative"
  ],
  "LAB_HOOKS": [
    "human A/B: equal localControlledBreakFit under different semantic roles",
    "human A/B: preferred-band center vs soft-falloff edge",
    "compare metric vs normalized target bands across formats",
    "estimate useful hard bounds empirically without auto-writing them into canon",
    "collect cases where score fits but humans still read accidental/error-like",
    "test target-weight sensitivity as lab-only evidence"
  ],
  "observation_record": {
    "moduleRef": "Compo12.04",
    "candidateRefs": [],
    "metricResults": [
      "ruleBreak.system.localControlledBreakFit",
      "ruleBreak.deviationTarget.componentFit.<targetRef>"
    ]
  },
  "topic12_local_chain": [
    "12.00 explicit intent",
    "12.01 explicit deviation magnitude",
    "12.02 hard protection + exception budget",
    "12.03 bounded candidates + explicit justification",
    "12.04 hard-gate synthesis + explicit local target fit"
  ],
  "stop_condition": "STOP after 12.04. Do not create closing audit in this file."
}