Flag competition.
Do not score it yet.

Descriptors become flags only through explicit rules

Observed policy-relative classification only

SecondaryCompetitionSignalBundle

SecondaryCompetitionRule

SecondaryCompetitionPolicy

RuleResult is boolean, not numeric quality

Preserve every trigger

SecondarySubordinationState

SecondaryCompetitionSubordinationSet

Derived attachments, never seed mutation

Observed state is policy-relative

Missing required evidence is not subordination

Rule meaning is identity-bearing

No signal has built-in competition meaning

Topic14 ownership chain

Wrong flag → review rule or upstream evidence

CANON → LAB → DATA → IDEAS

Visual laboratory hook

14.03 regression suite

Tests cover signal extraction, numeric/boolean/presence operators, explicit thresholds, required versus optional signals, simultaneous competition/inversion flags, state precedence, no-score semantics, cross-policy identity, immutable attachments and upstream ownership.

DATA FOR LAYOUT ENGINE

{
  "module": "Compo 14.03",
  "name": "competition_detection_subordination",
  "version": "1.0-canonical",
  "canonical_main_title": "Competition detection / subordination",
  "topic": "14_ВТОРИЧНЫЕ_МАССЫ_И_ПОДДЕРЖКА",
  "scope": "EXPLICIT_COMPETITION_SIGNAL_ADAPTER_RULE_POLICY_TRIGGER_FLAGS_AND_OBSERVED_SECONDARY_SUBORDINATION_CLASSIFICATION_ONLY",
  "main_topic_contract": {
    "topic_title": "Вторичные массы и поддержка",
    "topic_goal": "Описывает вторичные массы как поддержку доминанты: counterweight, spatial support, echo/repetition и контроль конкуренции с главным элементом.",
    "expected_output": "SecondaryMassRelation[], support score, competition flags",
    "planned_files": [
      "14.00 Secondary role system",
      "14.01 Secondary-to-dominant weight ratios",
      "14.02 Spatial counterweight and semantic support",
      "14.03 Competition detection / subordination",
      "14.04 Scoring, candidates and tests"
    ]
  },
  "ownership": {
    "owner": "Compo14.03",
    "owns": [
      "SecondaryCompetitionSignalKey taxonomy",
      "SecondaryCompetitionSignalBundle",
      "SecondaryCompetitionRuleOperator taxonomy",
      "SecondaryCompetitionEffect taxonomy",
      "SecondaryCompetitionRule",
      "SecondaryCompetitionPolicy",
      "SecondaryCompetitionRuleResult",
      "SecondaryCompetitionFlag",
      "SecondarySubordinationState taxonomy",
      "SecondaryCompetitionSubordinationDescriptor",
      "SecondaryCompetitionSubordinationSet",
      "SecondaryMassRelationCompetitionAttachment",
      "SecondarySupportSystemCompetitionAttachment",
      "same-policy observed classification contract",
      "identity/status/provenance rules for Topic14 competition/subordination layer",
      "non-mutating correction request for competition policy or upstream evidence"
    ],
    "does_not_own": [
      "visual mass calculation — Compo4",
      "secondary role evidence / support intent / relation seed — Compo14.00",
      "secondary-to-dominant weight ratio calculation — Compo14.01",
      "spatial counterweight / semantic support / echo evidence calculation — Compo14.02",
      "observed dominance / focal ranking / leader-set identity — Compo13",
      "generic hierarchy/subordination graph — Compo18",
      "global hierarchy priority",
      "global balance ownership",
      "target desirability of SUBORDINATED/COMPETING/INVERTED states — Compo14.04",
      "support scoring / candidate generation / final correction synthesis — Compo14.04",
      "foreign geometry / semantic / feature evidence mutation"
    ]
  },
  "consumes": [
    "valid Compo14.00 SecondaryMassRelationSeed[] and SecondarySupportSystemSeed",
    "valid Compo14.01 SecondaryWeightRatioSet / ratio descriptors when policy references WEIGHT_RATIO",
    "valid Compo14.02 SpatialSemanticSupportSet and underlying spatial/semantic/echo descriptors when referenced",
    "explicit SecondaryCompetitionPolicy"
  ],
  "provides": [
    "SecondaryCompetitionSignalBundle",
    "SecondaryCompetitionRule",
    "SecondaryCompetitionPolicy",
    "SecondaryCompetitionRuleResult",
    "SecondaryCompetitionFlag",
    "SecondaryCompetitionSubordinationDescriptor",
    "SecondaryCompetitionSubordinationSet",
    "SecondaryMassRelationCompetitionAttachment",
    "SecondarySupportSystemCompetitionAttachment",
    "Topic14.03 observation record"
  ],
  "owns_metrics": [],
  "metric_ownership_note": "14.03 owns boolean/ordinal observed competition descriptors and flags, but no MetricResult score, no support score, no target-fit score and no independent numeric vote.",
  "signal_key_taxonomy": {
    "WEIGHT_RATIO": "numeric signal from Compo14.01 SecondaryToDominantWeightRatioDescriptor.ratio",
    "DIRECTION_OPPOSITION_COSINE": "numeric signal from Compo14.02 SpatialCounterweightDescriptor.directionOppositionCosine",
    "RADIAL_LEVERAGE_RATIO": "numeric signal from Compo14.02 SpatialCounterweightDescriptor.radialLeverageRatio",
    "SEMANTIC_CONFLICT_FLAG": "boolean signal from Compo14.02 SemanticSupportResolution.conflict",
    "SEMANTIC_RELATION_PRESENT": "boolean presence of an explicitly named semantic relation kind in Compo14.02 SemanticSupportResolution",
    "ECHO_SIMILARITY": "numeric signal for one explicit featureKind from Compo14.02 EchoRepetitionSupportDescriptor"
  },
  "signal_bundle_schema": {
    "secondaryCompetitionSignalBundleRef": "stable identity",
    "secondaryMassRelationSeedRef": "14.00 relation",
    "secondarySubjectRef": "subject",
    "dominantSubjectRefs": "full anchor set",
    "weightRatioDescriptorRef": "14.01 descriptor or null",
    "weightRatio": "numeric or null",
    "spatialCounterweightDescriptorRef": "14.02 descriptor or null",
    "directionOppositionCosine": "numeric or null",
    "radialLeverageRatio": "numeric or null",
    "semanticSupportResolutionRef": "14.02 descriptor or null",
    "semanticConflict": "boolean or null",
    "semanticRelationKinds": "canonical set",
    "echoRepetitionSupportDescriptorRef": "14.02 descriptor or null",
    "echoSimilarityByFeatureKind": "map featureKind -> numeric similarity",
    "statusBySignalFamily": "explicit per-family OK|N_A|INVALID",
    "status": "OK|N_A|INVALID",
    "reasonCode": "explicit",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "firewall": "bundle adapts existing descriptors only and does not reinterpret them before an explicit competition rule is applied"
  },
  "rule_operator_taxonomy": {
    "GT": "value > threshold",
    "GTE": "value >= threshold",
    "LT": "value < threshold",
    "LTE": "value <= threshold",
    "BETWEEN_INCLUSIVE": "low <= value <= high",
    "OUTSIDE_EXCLUSIVE": "value < low or value > high",
    "IS_TRUE": "boolean true",
    "IS_FALSE": "boolean false",
    "PRESENT": "named semantic relation is present",
    "ABSENT": "named semantic relation is absent"
  },
  "effect_taxonomy": {
    "COMPETITION": "trigger creates an observed competition flag",
    "INVERSION": "trigger creates an observed inversion flag"
  },
  "competition_rule_schema": {
    "secondaryCompetitionRuleRef": "stable identity",
    "ruleSourceRef": "explicit source",
    "ruleSourceOwnerRef": "owner",
    "signalKey": "one signal key from taxonomy",
    "featureKind": "required only for ECHO_SIMILARITY",
    "semanticRelationKind": "required only for SEMANTIC_RELATION_PRESENT",
    "operator": "compatible operator",
    "threshold": "finite numeric for GT/GTE/LT/LTE",
    "low": "finite numeric for BETWEEN/OUTSIDE",
    "high": "finite numeric > low for BETWEEN/OUTSIDE",
    "effect": "COMPETITION|INVERSION",
    "required": "boolean; missing required signal propagates N_A, missing optional signal yields rule N_A but may be omitted from classification",
    "provenance": "canonical provenance class",
    "status": "OK|INVALID",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "firewall": "threshold/operator/effect are explicit policy data; no threshold is universal"
  },
  "competition_policy_schema": {
    "secondaryCompetitionPolicyRef": "stable identity",
    "policySourceRef": "explicit source",
    "policySourceOwnerRef": "owner",
    "rules": "non-empty canonical set of valid SecondaryCompetitionRule",
    "requiredSignalCompleteness": "required rules must resolve; optional rules may be N_A",
    "statePrecedence": "fixed v1 semantic specificity INVERTED > COMPETING > SUBORDINATED",
    "provenance": "canonical provenance class",
    "status": "OK|INVALID",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "default": "NONE — no implicit thresholds, no implicit signal meanings, no implicit ratio competition law"
  },
  "rule_result_schema": {
    "secondaryCompetitionRuleResultRef": "stable identity",
    "secondaryMassRelationSeedRef": "relation",
    "secondaryCompetitionRuleRef": "rule",
    "signalKey": "rule signal",
    "observedValue": "numeric/boolean/relation-presence result or null",
    "triggered": "boolean or null when N_A",
    "effect": "copied rule effect",
    "required": "copied rule required flag",
    "status": "OK|N_A|INVALID",
    "reasonCode": "explicit",
    "dependsOn": "exact upstream descriptor refs used",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "firewall": "rule result is a boolean condition result, not a score or vote"
  },
  "competition_flag_schema": {
    "secondaryCompetitionFlagRef": "stable identity",
    "secondaryMassRelationSeedRef": "relation",
    "secondaryCompetitionRuleResultRef": "triggered rule result",
    "flagKind": "COMPETITION|INVERSION",
    "signalKey": "source signal",
    "evidenceRefs": "exact lineage refs",
    "status": "OPEN|INVALID",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "firewall": "flag records an observed policy trigger only; it is not a target violation score"
  },
  "subordination_state_taxonomy": {
    "SUBORDINATED": "all required rules resolved and no COMPETITION/INVERSION rule triggered",
    "COMPETING": "at least one COMPETITION rule triggered and no INVERSION rule triggered",
    "INVERTED": "at least one INVERSION rule triggered; any simultaneous competition flags remain preserved"
  },
  "competition_descriptor_schema": {
    "secondaryCompetitionSubordinationDescriptorRef": "stable identity",
    "secondaryMassRelationSeedRef": "relation",
    "secondaryCandidateRef": "candidate",
    "secondarySubjectRef": "subject",
    "dominantSubjectRefs": "full anchor set",
    "secondaryCompetitionPolicyRef": "explicit policy",
    "secondaryCompetitionSignalBundleRef": "signal bundle",
    "ruleResultRefs": "one result per policy rule",
    "triggeredCompetitionFlagRefs": "all triggered COMPETITION flags",
    "triggeredInversionFlagRefs": "all triggered INVERSION flags",
    "observedState": "SUBORDINATED|COMPETING|INVERTED",
    "status": "OK|N_A|INVALID",
    "reasonCode": "explicit",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "firewall": "observedState is policy-relative classification only; SUBORDINATED is not automatically good and INVERTED is not a numeric penalty"
  },
  "competition_set_schema": {
    "secondaryCompetitionSubordinationSetRef": "stable identity",
    "dominanceScopeRef": "scope",
    "dominanceAnchorBindingRef": "anchor",
    "secondaryCandidateSetRef": "candidate set",
    "secondaryCompetitionPolicyRef": "shared policy",
    "descriptorRefs": "one competition descriptor per relation",
    "secondarySubjectRefs": "candidate subjects",
    "stateBySecondarySubject": "subject -> observedState",
    "competitionFlagRefs": "all competition flags",
    "inversionFlagRefs": "all inversion flags",
    "status": "OK|N_A|INVALID",
    "reasonCode": "explicit",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "firewall": "set is observed classification only; no support-score aggregation and no cross-policy ranking"
  },
  "relation_competition_attachment_schema": {
    "secondaryMassRelationCompetitionAttachmentRef": "stable identity",
    "secondaryMassRelationSeedRef": "exact 14.00 relation",
    "secondaryCompetitionSubordinationDescriptorRef": "exact 14.03 descriptor",
    "status": "OK",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "firewall": "derived attachment never mutates competitionSubordinationRef on the 14.00 relation seed"
  },
  "system_competition_attachment_schema": {
    "secondarySupportSystemCompetitionAttachmentRef": "stable identity",
    "secondarySupportSystemSeedRef": "exact 14.00 system seed",
    "secondaryCompetitionSubordinationSetRef": "exact 14.03 set",
    "relationCompetitionAttachmentRefs": "canonical set",
    "status": "OK",
    "mutationAllowed": false,
    "firewall": "derived attachment never mutates competitionSubordinationSetRef on the 14.00 system seed"
  },
  "classification_policy": {
    "requiredRuleNA": "descriptor N_A; do not silently classify SUBORDINATED from incomplete required evidence",
    "optionalRuleNA": "rule result N_A; classification may proceed only because policy explicitly marked that rule optional",
    "anyInversion": "observedState INVERTED",
    "noInversionAnyCompetition": "observedState COMPETING",
    "noTriggeredFlags": "observedState SUBORDINATED",
    "firewall": "state precedence is semantic specificity inside this module, not global design-rule priority"
  },
  "status_policy": {
    "missingRequiredSignal": "N_A",
    "missingOptionalSignal": "rule-level N_A; may be ignored only because rule.required=false",
    "invalidUpstreamSignal": "INVALID",
    "policyInvalid": "INVALID",
    "noRules": "INVALID",
    "allRequiredResolvedNoTrigger": "OK + SUBORDINATED",
    "competitionTrigger": "OK + COMPETING unless any inversion trigger also exists",
    "inversionTrigger": "OK + INVERTED",
    "setIncomplete": "N_A; no silent partial set",
    "N_A_not_zero": true
  },
  "comparability_contract": {
    "requires": [
      "same dominanceScopeRef",
      "same dominanceAnchorBindingRef",
      "same secondaryCompetitionPolicyRef",
      "same upstream ratio/spatial/semantic/echo lineage for compared observations",
      "same snapshot lineage through upstream descriptors"
    ],
    "allows": "within-policy observed-state comparison only",
    "forbids": [
      "cross-policy state ranking as if thresholds were universal",
      "cross-snapshot classification comparison without explicit study contract",
      "state-to-support-score conversion",
      "state-to-global-hierarchy conversion",
      "using lexical rule order as severity or priority"
    ]
  },
  "critical_firewalls": [
    "competition policy must be explicit",
    "no universal competition threshold",
    "no universal inversion threshold",
    "no implicit weight-ratio threshold",
    "no implicit opposition threshold",
    "no implicit leverage threshold",
    "no implicit semantic-conflict competition law",
    "no implicit echo-similarity competition law",
    "weight ratio != competition flag without explicit rule",
    "ratio near 1 != automatically competing",
    "ratio above 1 != automatically inverted",
    "directionOppositionCosine != competition flag without explicit rule",
    "radialLeverageRatio != competition flag without explicit rule",
    "semantic relation CONFLICTS != competition flag without explicit rule",
    "semantic relation SUPPORTS != subordination proof",
    "echo similarity != competition flag without explicit rule",
    "echo similarity 1 != automatic competition",
    "rule result != score",
    "competition flag != numeric penalty",
    "inversion flag != numeric penalty",
    "SUBORDINATED != support score 1",
    "COMPETING != support score 0",
    "INVERTED != automatic hard reject",
    "observedState != target state",
    "observedState is policy-relative",
    "optional missing rule can be ignored only when explicitly optional",
    "missing required signal => N_A, not SUBORDINATED",
    "N_A != SUBORDINATED",
    "N_A != 0",
    "rule order != priority",
    "state precedence != global rule priority",
    "signal confidence != trigger threshold",
    "signal confidence != state severity",
    "candidate count != competition pressure",
    "flag count != competition score",
    "multiple flags are preserved and not averaged",
    "INVERTED may preserve simultaneous COMPETITION flags",
    "cross-policy state ranking is not canonical",
    "visual mass ownership remains Compo4",
    "secondary role ownership remains Compo14.00",
    "weight-ratio ownership remains Compo14.01",
    "spatial/semantic/echo ownership remains Compo14.02",
    "dominance ownership remains Compo13",
    "generic hierarchy/subordination graph remains Compo18 territory",
    "target desirability is deferred to 14.04",
    "support scoring is deferred to 14.04",
    "candidate generation/variation is deferred to 14.04",
    "14.03 owns no MetricResult",
    "14.03 owns no independent numeric vote",
    "relation attachment != relation-seed mutation",
    "system attachment != system-seed mutation",
    "global hierarchy is not owned by 14.03",
    "global balance is not owned by 14.03",
    "local != global",
    "descriptor != score",
    "module execution order != rule priority",
    "correction request != foreign mutation",
    "no universal beautyScore",
    "IDEA != CANON",
    "EXPERIMENT != CANON"
  ],
  "identity_policy": {
    "secondaryCompetitionSignalBundleRef": "hash(relation, exact upstream descriptor refs, extracted signal payload, family statuses)",
    "secondaryCompetitionRuleRef": "hash(source/owner, signal key, feature/relation selector, operator, thresholds, effect, required, provenance)",
    "secondaryCompetitionPolicyRef": "hash(source/owner, canonical rule refs, provenance)",
    "secondaryCompetitionRuleResultRef": "hash(relation, rule, observed value, triggered, status, lineage refs)",
    "secondaryCompetitionFlagRef": "hash(relation, rule result, flag kind, signal key, evidence refs)",
    "secondaryCompetitionSubordinationDescriptorRef": "hash(relation, candidate, policy, signal bundle, rule results, flags, observedState, status)",
    "secondaryCompetitionSubordinationSetRef": "hash(scope, anchor, candidate set, policy, descriptor refs, state map, flag refs)",
    "secondaryMassRelationCompetitionAttachmentRef": "hash(relation seed, competition descriptor)",
    "secondarySupportSystemCompetitionAttachmentRef": "hash(system seed, competition set, relation attachments)",
    "excluded_from_identity": [
      "display label",
      "display color",
      "free-form comment"
    ]
  },
  "correction_request_schema": {
    "requestRef": "stable identity",
    "targetOwnerRef": "competition-policy owner or upstream evidence owner",
    "reasonCode": "COMPETITION_RULE_WRONG|COMPETITION_THRESHOLD_WRONG|COMPETITION_EFFECT_WRONG|REQUIRED_SIGNAL_POLICY_WRONG|WEIGHT_SIGNAL_WRONG|SPATIAL_SIGNAL_WRONG|SEMANTIC_SIGNAL_WRONG|ECHO_SIGNAL_WRONG|OBSERVED_STATE_WRONG",
    "subjectRef": "secondary subject or null for policy issue",
    "evidenceRefs": "canonical refs",
    "suggestedAction": "non-mutating review request",
    "status": "OPEN|INVALID",
    "mutationAllowed": false
  },
  "deferred_downstream": {
    "14.04": [
      "desired target support/subordination profiles",
      "component and composite support scoring",
      "mapping observed SUBORDINATED/COMPETING/INVERTED to target fit",
      "candidate generation/variation",
      "final Topic14 correction synthesis",
      "consolidated Topic14 tests"
    ]
  },
  "IDEAS_REFS": [
    "IDEA-01 full human test after all 72 topics; compare human competition judgments with explicit policy triggers",
    "IDEA-02 semantics needed before placement; semantic conflict remains owner-qualified evidence rather than self-interpreting truth",
    "IDEA-03 explicit rule priorities; competition rule order never becomes hidden global priority",
    "IDEA-04 collect structured data for future composition model",
    "IDEA-05 preserve reasons for human corrections",
    "IDEA-06 structured machine-readable layer for website",
    "IDEA-07 graphics-for-post-text research remains downstream/separate"
  ],
  "DATA_CAPTURE": [
    "sceneRef",
    "dominanceScopeRef",
    "dominanceAnchorBindingRef",
    "secondaryCandidateSetRef",
    "secondarySupportSystemSeedRef",
    "secondaryMassRelationSeedRefs[]",
    "secondaryCompetitionPolicyRef",
    "secondaryCompetitionRuleRefs[]",
    "secondaryCompetitionSignalBundleRefs[]",
    "weightRatioSignalsBySubject",
    "directionOppositionSignalsBySubject",
    "radialLeverageSignalsBySubject",
    "semanticConflictSignalsBySubject",
    "semanticRelationKindsBySubject",
    "echoSimilaritiesBySubjectAndFeature",
    "ruleResultRefs[]",
    "triggeredCompetitionFlagRefs[]",
    "triggeredInversionFlagRefs[]",
    "observedStateBySecondarySubject",
    "secondaryCompetitionSubordinationDescriptorRefs[]",
    "secondaryCompetitionSubordinationSetRef",
    "humanReasonCodes[]",
    "future targetProfileRef",
    "future secondaryEvaluationRefs[]"
  ],
  "DEFERRED_SEMANTIC_INPUTS": [
    "whether SUBORDINATED is desirable for a specific style",
    "whether deliberate secondary competition is desired",
    "whether inversion is intentionally allowed",
    "target competition/subordination profile",
    "global hierarchy priority",
    "style-specific penalties/rewards for each observed state"
  ],
  "HUMAN_FEEDBACK_HOOKS": [
    "COMPETITION_RULE_WRONG",
    "COMPETITION_THRESHOLD_TOO_LOW",
    "COMPETITION_THRESHOLD_TOO_HIGH",
    "INVERSION_THRESHOLD_TOO_LOW",
    "INVERSION_THRESHOLD_TOO_HIGH",
    "RULE_EFFECT_WRONG",
    "RULE_REQUIRED_FLAG_WRONG",
    "WEIGHT_RATIO_SIGNAL_WRONG",
    "OPPOSITION_SIGNAL_WRONG",
    "LEVERAGE_SIGNAL_WRONG",
    "SEMANTIC_CONFLICT_SIGNAL_WRONG",
    "SEMANTIC_RELATION_SIGNAL_WRONG",
    "ECHO_SIGNAL_WRONG",
    "SECONDARY_READS_SUBORDINATED",
    "SECONDARY_READS_COMPETING",
    "SECONDARY_READS_INVERTED",
    "MULTIPLE_FLAGS_SHOULD_BE_PRESERVED",
    "OPTIONAL_SIGNAL_SHOULD_BE_REQUIRED",
    "REQUIRED_SIGNAL_SHOULD_BE_OPTIONAL",
    "OBSERVED_STATE_SHOULD_NOT_BE_SCORE"
  ],
  "CONFLICT_PRIORITY_ASSUMPTIONS": [
    "module execution order is not priority",
    "rule serialization order is not rule priority",
    "signal confidence is not trigger priority",
    "INVERTED > COMPETING > SUBORDINATED is local state specificity, not global design priority",
    "simultaneous flags remain preserved rather than averaged",
    "future reviewed global conflict-priority owner remains authoritative"
  ],
  "LAB_HOOKS": [
    "human study: weight-ratio thresholds versus perceived competition",
    "human study: perceived inversion versus ratio above one",
    "test whether semantic CONFLICTS actually reads as visual competition",
    "test whether high echo similarity increases or reduces competition in different styles",
    "compare optional versus required signal policies",
    "collect scenes where SUBORDINATED is undesirable because deliberate tension is intended",
    "collect scenes with simultaneous competition and inversion flags"
  ],
  "observation_record": {
    "moduleRef": "Compo14.03",
    "metricResults": [],
    "secondaryEvaluationRefs": []
  },
  "stop_condition": "STOP after 14.03. Do not create 14.04 in this module."
}