Explicit tolerance.
One local vote.

ProportionToleranceProfile {
  distanceKind: ABSOLUTE_RATIO_DELTA | RELATIVE_RATIO_DELTA | LOG_RATIO_DISTANCE,
  threshold: finite >= 0,
  orderedRatioSemantics: true,
  reciprocalAutoMatch: false,
  mutationAllowed: false
}

MetricResult {
  key, owner, value, applicability, confidence, status, provenance,
  composite, componentOf, dependsOn[], derivedFrom[],
  scoringGroup, independentVoteAllowed, evidence, repairHints[]
}

generationMode = FAILED_APPLICABLE_COMPONENTS_ONLY
evaluationOutcomeRequired = KEEP
seed = EXPLICIT
maxCandidates = 1..64
fullCartesianProductAllowed = false
generationOnNA = false
generationOnInvalid = false

Tests cover tolerance math, ordered orientation, explicit targets, N_A/INVALID, MetricResult constitution, one-vote budget, comparison, bounded repair and ownership firewalls.

{
  "module": "Compo 17.04",
  "name": "tolerance_scoring_and_tests",
  "version": "1.0-canonical",
  "canonical_main_title": "Tolerance, scoring and tests",
  "topic": "17_ПРОПОРЦИИ_ФОРМ_И_ЧАСТЕЙ_К_ЦЕЛОМУ",
  "scope": "EXPLICIT_ORDERED_RATIO_TOLERANCE_REFERENCE_DEVIATION_LOCAL_TARGET_SCORING_AND_BOUNDED_OWNER_ROUTED_REPAIR_ONLY",
  "main_topic_contract": {
    "topic_title": "Пропорции форм и частей к целому",
    "topic_goal": "Формализует пропорции формы и part-to-whole relations: aspect ratios, повторяемые ratio families, допустимые отклонения и style-specific пропорциональные системы.",
    "expected_output": "ProportionRelation[], ratio families, tolerance profiles",
    "planned_files": [
      "17.00 Proportion schema and reference ratios",
      "17.01 Shape aspect ratios",
      "17.02 Part-to-whole ratios",
      "17.03 Repeated proportional systems",
      "17.04 Tolerance, scoring and tests"
    ]
  },
  "ownership": {
    "owner": "Compo17.04",
    "owns": [
      "ProportionToleranceProfile",
      "RatioToleranceEvaluation",
      "ProportionTargetProfile",
      "ProportionEvaluationProfile",
      "Topic17 component MetricResults",
      "Topic17 composite MetricResult proportion.system.localTargetProfileFit",
      "ProportionRepairRoute",
      "ProportionRepairCandidateSetPolicy",
      "ProportionRepairRequest",
      "ProportionRepairCandidateSet",
      "explicit ordered-ratio deviation math",
      "explicit style/context target fit",
      "Topic17 independent numeric vote budget",
      "bounded deterministic owner-routed repair candidate generation",
      "final Topic17 regression tests"
    ],
    "does_not_own": [
      "ProportionSubject / ProportionMeasureBinding / ProportionRelation identity — Compo17.00",
      "reference-ratio declaration identity — Compo17.00",
      "shape-axis measurements / observed shape aspect ratios — Compo17.01",
      "part/whole membership / observed part-to-whole ratios — Compo17.02",
      "exact ratio families / repeated proportional systems — Compo17.03",
      "raw geometry measurement — upstream geometry/measurement owners",
      "object-to-object scale differentiation — Topic16",
      "transform scale parameter — Compo3.05",
      "visual mass — Compo4",
      "format normalization / global scale invariance — Compo6.03",
      "dominance / focal ranking — Compo13",
      "microdetail size/contrast role envelopes — Topic15",
      "generic hierarchy/subordination — Compo18",
      "semantic importance",
      "global balance",
      "final-layout ranking",
      "universal beautyScore",
      "foreign geometry/style/semantic mutation"
    ]
  },
  "consumes": [
    "valid Compo17.00 ReferenceRatioDefinition[] and ordered ProportionRelation lineage",
    "valid Compo17.01 ShapeAspectRatioDescriptor[]",
    "valid Compo17.02 PartToWholeRatioDescriptor[]",
    "valid Compo17.03 RatioFamilyDefinition / RatioFamilyMembership / RepeatedProportionalSystemDescriptor",
    "explicit ProportionToleranceProfile",
    "explicit ProportionTargetProfile",
    "explicit ProportionEvaluationProfile"
  ],
  "provides": [
    "ProportionToleranceProfile[]",
    "RatioToleranceEvaluation[]",
    "Topic17 component MetricResult[]",
    "proportion.system.localTargetProfileFit composite MetricResult",
    "ProportionRepairCandidateSet",
    "Topic17.04 final evaluation record"
  ],
  "metric_keys": {
    "components": [
      "proportion.target.componentFit.shapeAspectReference",
      "proportion.target.componentFit.partToWholeReference",
      "proportion.target.componentFit.ratioFamilySystem",
      "proportion.target.componentFit.repeatedSystem"
    ],
    "composite": "proportion.system.localTargetProfileFit",
    "owner": "Compo17.04",
    "scoringGroup": "proportion-local",
    "independentNumericVoteCount": 1
  },
  "metric_result_constitution": [
    "key",
    "owner",
    "value",
    "applicability",
    "confidence",
    "status",
    "provenance",
    "composite",
    "componentOf",
    "dependsOn[]",
    "derivedFrom[]",
    "scoringGroup",
    "independentVoteAllowed",
    "evidence",
    "repairHints[]"
  ],
  "tolerance_profile_schema": {
    "selection": "EXPLICIT_ONLY",
    "distanceKind": "ABSOLUTE_RATIO_DELTA|RELATIVE_RATIO_DELTA|LOG_RATIO_DISTANCE",
    "threshold": "finite >= 0",
    "orderedRatioSemantics": true,
    "reciprocalAutoMatch": false,
    "crossContextMatch": false,
    "crossRelationKindMatch": false,
    "universalDefault": false,
    "mutationAllowed": false
  },
  "evaluation_profile_schema": {
    "componentWeights": "explicit nonnegative weights",
    "zeroWeightPolicy": "EXCLUDE_FROM_DENOMINATOR",
    "missingObservedPolicy": "COMPOSITE_N_A",
    "lineageMismatchPolicy": "COMPOSITE_N_A",
    "invalidPolicy": "COMPOSITE_INVALID",
    "mismatchPolicy": "SOFT_ZERO_KEEP",
    "normalization": "WEIGHTED_MEAN_OVER_INCLUDED_COMPONENTS",
    "mutationAllowed": false
  },
  "generator_policy_schema": {
    "generationMode": "FAILED_APPLICABLE_COMPONENTS_ONLY",
    "evaluationOutcomeRequired": "KEEP",
    "componentSelectionOrder": "EXPLICIT_LIST",
    "seed": "EXPLICIT",
    "maxCandidates": "1..64",
    "hardFilterInvalidRoutes": true,
    "deduplication": "IDENTITY_EQUIVALENT_REPAIR_REQUEST",
    "diversityPruning": "MAX_ONE_PER_COMPONENT_REPAIR_KIND_IN_V1",
    "fullCartesianProductAllowed": false,
    "generationOnNA": false,
    "generationOnInvalid": false,
    "candidateIsRepairedLayout": false,
    "mutationAllowed": false
  },
  "critical_firewalls": [
    "tolerance is explicit; no implicit epsilon",
    "ordered ratio orientation is preserved through tolerance evaluation",
    "ratio may be <1, =1 or >1",
    "no automatic ratio inversion",
    "no reciprocal match unless separately declared as a reference",
    "reference ratio != universal ideal",
    "no universal golden ratio",
    "no implicit 1.618 preference",
    "no universal 4:3 preference",
    "no universal 3:2 preference",
    "no universal square preference",
    "near-equal matching exists only through an explicit tolerance profile",
    "tolerance match != desirability unless an explicit target requests that reference",
    "distance descriptor != score",
    "component fit != global quality",
    "localTargetProfileFit != beautyScore",
    "localTargetProfileFit != global layout quality",
    "localTargetProfileFit != generic hierarchy score",
    "localTargetProfileFit != final-layout rank",
    "higher local fit != automatic final-layout winner",
    "cross-target comparison forbidden",
    "cross-evaluation-profile comparison forbidden",
    "target does not redefine upstream observed ratios",
    "target does not redefine exact ratio families",
    "target does not redefine part/whole semantics",
    "target does not redefine shape-axis semantics",
    "component MetricResults are not independent numeric votes",
    "exactly one independent numeric vote in Topic17",
    "one metric = one owner",
    "N_A != 0",
    "INVALID != 0",
    "local != global",
    "geometry != interpretation",
    "descriptor != score",
    "heuristic != law",
    "correction request != foreign mutation",
    "module execution order != rule priority",
    "no universal beautyScore",
    "composite-first scoring",
    "candidate generation is bounded, seeded, deterministic and reproducible",
    "no full Cartesian product",
    "generator runs only under KEEP with failed applicable components",
    "no generation on N_A",
    "no generation on INVALID",
    "repair candidate != repaired layout",
    "generator ordinal != score",
    "repair request != foreign mutation",
    "generator cannot mutate geometry",
    "generator cannot mutate semantics",
    "generator cannot mutate 17.01 observations",
    "generator cannot mutate 17.02 observations",
    "generator cannot mutate 17.03 family/system observations",
    "generator cannot mutate 17.00 reference identity",
    "IDEA != CANON",
    "EXPERIMENT != CANON"
  ],
  "topic16_firewall": {
    "Topic16": "unordered object-to-object scale differentiation and larger-to-smaller ratios",
    "Topic17_04": "ordered proportion target/tolerance evaluation",
    "reusedScaleRatioDescriptor": false,
    "largerToSmallerCanonicalizationImported": false,
    "scaleClassesImported": false,
    "scaleLaddersImported": false
  },
  "hook_families": {
    "IDEAS_REFS": [
      "human tests after all 72 topics",
      "study tolerance perception by style/context",
      "calibrate target profiles empirically"
    ],
    "DATA_CAPTURE": [
      "scopeRef",
      "targetProfileRef",
      "evaluationProfileRef",
      "toleranceProfileRefs[]",
      "ratioEvaluationRefs[]",
      "componentMetricResultRefs[]",
      "compositeMetricResultRef",
      "repairCandidateRefs[]"
    ],
    "DEFERRED_SEMANTIC_INPUTS": [
      "human preference labels",
      "style-specific target desirability beyond explicit declared profiles"
    ],
    "HUMAN_FEEDBACK_HOOKS": [
      "tolerance too strict/loose",
      "reference target correction",
      "repair-route usefulness"
    ],
    "CONFLICT_PRIORITY_ASSUMPTIONS": [
      "module order is not priority",
      "higher fit is not global winner",
      "tolerance source owner remains explicit"
    ],
    "LAB_HOOKS": [
      "compare absolute vs relative vs log distance",
      "fit calibration",
      "repair candidate acceptance rate"
    ]
  },
  "data_for_layout_engine": {
    "module": "Compo17.04",
    "topic17ProgressAfterThisModule": "5/5 local",
    "ownsMetrics": true,
    "componentMetricCount": 4,
    "independentNumericVotes": 1,
    "independentVoteKey": "proportion.system.localTargetProfileFit",
    "scoringGroup": "proportion-local",
    "generatorBounded": true,
    "nextOwner": null,
    "topicCompleteAfterThisModule": true,
    "stopAfterThisModule": true
  }
}