Asymmetry can be balanced.
The target must be explicit.

Off-center, unequal mass shares and non-zero moments remain valid descriptors. Whether they fit a composition is decided only by the explicit profile.

Tests cover exact source adapters, explicit off-center/unequal-mass targets, MetricResult constitution, one-vote budget, N_A/zero semantics, owner-routed bounded candidate generation, no truncation, deterministic ordering, no mutation, Topic21/Topic23 firewalls and numeric sweeps over all four source families.

{
  "module": "Compo 22.04",
  "name": "scoring_candidates_and_tests",
  "version": "1.0-canonical",
  "canonical_main_title": "Scoring, candidates and tests",
  "topic": "22_АСИММЕТРИЧНЫЙ_БАЛАНС",
  "scope": "EXPLICIT_LOCAL_ASYMMETRIC_BALANCE_TARGET_PROFILE_SCORING_ONE_COMPOSITE_METRICRESULT_AND_BOUNDED_OWNER_ROUTED_NONMUTATING_CANDIDATES_OVER_VALID_22_00_TO_22_03_LINEAGE_ONLY",
  "main_topic_contract": {
    "topic_title": "Асимметричный баланс",
    "topic_goal": "Описывает асимметричный баланс через visual center of mass, moments/плечи, regional distribution и counterweights, не требуя зеркального соответствия.",
    "expected_output": "VisualCentroid, mass moments, balance descriptors",
    "planned_files": [
      "22.00 Asymmetric balance model",
      "22.01 Visual center of mass",
      "22.02 Torque-like moment descriptors",
      "22.03 Counterweight and regional mass distribution",
      "22.04 Scoring, candidates and tests"
    ]
  },
  "ownership": {
    "owner": "Compo22.04",
    "owns": [
      "AsymmetricBalanceTargetSourceKind taxonomy",
      "AsymmetricBalanceTargetFamily taxonomy",
      "AsymmetricBalanceLocalTargetItem",
      "AsymmetricBalanceLocalTargetProfile",
      "AsymmetricBalanceTargetItemEvaluation",
      "four Topic22 component MetricResults",
      "one composite MetricResult asymmetricBalance.system.localTargetProfileFit",
      "AsymmetricBalanceLocalEvaluationSet",
      "AsymmetricBalanceScoringAttachment",
      "AsymmetricBalanceRepairActionKind taxonomy",
      "AsymmetricBalanceRepairRoute",
      "AsymmetricBalanceRepairCandidatePolicy",
      "AsymmetricBalanceRepairCandidate",
      "AsymmetricBalanceRepairCandidateSet",
      "explicit local target evaluation over 22.01/22.02/22.03 descriptors",
      "Topic22 independent numeric vote budget",
      "bounded deterministic failed-item-only owner-routed candidate generation",
      "final Topic22 regression tests"
    ],
    "does_not_own": [
      "AsymmetricBalanceModel / subject / frame / position / mass binding identities — Compo22.00",
      "VisualCentroid or contribution evidence resolution — Compo22.01",
      "reference axes / signed arms / torque-like moment descriptors — Compo22.02",
      "region identity / membership / counterweight pair descriptors — Compo22.03",
      "visual-mass extraction or semantics — Compo4 / foreign owner",
      "mirror symmetry — Topic21",
      "radial balance — Topic23",
      "dominance / hierarchy / focal ranking",
      "global beautyScore",
      "final-layout ranking",
      "automatic physical layout mutation",
      "foreign geometry/mass/style/semantic mutation"
    ]
  },
  "source_kinds": [
    "CENTROID_NORMALIZED_DISTANCE",
    "AXIS_NET_MOMENT_RATIO",
    "REGION_MASS_SHARE",
    "COUNTERWEIGHT_COMPENSATION"
  ],
  "families": [
    "CENTROID",
    "MOMENT",
    "REGIONAL_MASS",
    "COUNTERWEIGHT"
  ],
  "source_to_family": {
    "CENTROID_NORMALIZED_DISTANCE": "CENTROID",
    "AXIS_NET_MOMENT_RATIO": "MOMENT",
    "REGION_MASS_SHARE": "REGIONAL_MASS",
    "COUNTERWEIGHT_COMPENSATION": "COUNTERWEIGHT"
  },
  "target_semantics": {
    "CENTROID_NORMALIZED_DISTANCE": "distance from explicitly declared target point divided by explicitly declared positive normalizationDistance; no default center",
    "AXIS_NET_MOMENT_RATIO": "abs(signedNetMoment)/absoluteMomentSum; exact zero denominator with zero net resolves to 0",
    "REGION_MASS_SHARE": "uses exact Compo22.03 regionalMassShare",
    "COUNTERWEIGHT_COMPENSATION": "uses exact Compo22.03 compensationFraction; null stays N_A and is never coerced to 0",
    "fit": "inclusive membership in an explicit targetBand; no hidden ideal or tolerance"
  },
  "metric_contract": {
    "component_keys": [
      "asymmetricBalance.target.componentFit.centroid",
      "asymmetricBalance.target.componentFit.moment",
      "asymmetricBalance.target.componentFit.regionalMass",
      "asymmetricBalance.target.componentFit.counterweight"
    ],
    "composite_key": "asymmetricBalance.system.localTargetProfileFit",
    "owner": "Compo22.04",
    "scoringGroup": "asymmetric-balance-local",
    "component_metrics": {
      "composite": false,
      "independentVoteAllowed": false,
      "componentOf": "asymmetricBalance.system.localTargetProfileFit"
    },
    "composite_metric": {
      "composite": true,
      "independentVoteAllowed": true,
      "componentOf": null
    },
    "component_value": "explicit item-weighted mean of binary inclusive target-band fits for one APPLY family",
    "composite_value": "explicit family-weighted mean of applicable component MetricResults",
    "cross_profile_comparison": "forbidden unless a foreign comparison owner explicitly defines it"
  },
  "owns_metrics": [
    "asymmetricBalance.target.componentFit.centroid",
    "asymmetricBalance.target.componentFit.moment",
    "asymmetricBalance.target.componentFit.regionalMass",
    "asymmetricBalance.target.componentFit.counterweight",
    "asymmetricBalance.system.localTargetProfileFit"
  ],
  "independent_numeric_votes": {
    "count": 1,
    "key": "asymmetricBalance.system.localTargetProfileFit",
    "owner": "Compo22.04",
    "scoringGroup": "asymmetric-balance-local",
    "component_metrics_independentVoteAllowed": false,
    "composite_independentVoteAllowed": true
  },
  "candidate_generation": {
    "selection": "FAILED_APPLICABLE_TARGET_ITEMS_ONLY",
    "routes": "EXPLICIT_ROUTE_RECORDS_ONLY",
    "seed": "required explicit deterministic seed",
    "bounds": {
      "maxRoutes": "1..512",
      "maxCandidates": "1..128"
    },
    "overflow": "N_A_NO_TRUNCATION",
    "dedupe": "exact canonical route identity",
    "ordering": "stable seed hash + canonical tie break",
    "fullCartesian": false,
    "autoRouteInference": false,
    "autoGeometryMutation": false,
    "candidateScore": null,
    "candidateMutationAllowed": false,
    "candidateMeaning": "owner-routed review request, not a physical edit and not a promise of improvement"
  },
  "repair_action_kinds": [
    "REVIEW_POSITION",
    "REVIEW_VISUAL_MASS",
    "REVIEW_REFERENCE_AXIS",
    "REVIEW_REGION_ASSIGNMENT",
    "REVIEW_COUNTERWEIGHT_CONFIGURATION",
    "REVIEW_TARGET_PROFILE"
  ],
  "status_semantics": {
    "OK": "valid exact Topic22 lineage + explicit compatible target profile; candidate set OK when every failed applicable item has an explicit valid route and bounds hold",
    "N_A": "missing source, upstream N_A, target family IGNORE, counterweight compensation null, missing repair route, or bounded overflow; no guessing/truncation/coercion",
    "INVALID": "malformed profile/route/policy, source lineage mismatch, invalid upstream descriptor, unit mismatch, or impossible numeric invariant",
    "zero_note": "centroid distance 0, net-moment ratio 0, mass share 0, compensation 0 and metric fit 0 are valid numbers; N_A != 0"
  },
  "firewalls": [
    "off-center centroid is not automatically bad",
    "centered centroid is not automatically good",
    "unequal regional mass shares are not automatically bad",
    "equal regional mass shares are not automatically required",
    "nonzero net moment is not automatically bad",
    "counterweight compensation below 1 is not automatically bad",
    "target profile is local and explicit, not a universal asymmetry law",
    "component MetricResults are not independent votes",
    "exactly one Topic22 independent numeric vote",
    "candidate ordinal is not score",
    "candidate != mutation",
    "candidate != guaranteed improvement",
    "no mirror-pair requirement from Topic21",
    "no radial semantics from Topic23",
    "no global beautyScore",
    "no final-layout rank"
  ],
  "metric_result_fields": [
    "key",
    "owner",
    "value",
    "applicability",
    "confidence",
    "status",
    "provenance",
    "composite",
    "componentOf",
    "dependsOn[]",
    "derivedFrom[]",
    "scoringGroup",
    "independentVoteAllowed",
    "evidence",
    "repairHints[]"
  ],
  "hooks": {
    "IDEAS_REFS[]": [
      "asymmetric target presets by layout class",
      "learned explicit target profiles after LAB validation",
      "counterweight route libraries",
      "human-reviewed off-center balance corpora",
      "local balance explainability"
    ],
    "DATA_CAPTURE[]": [
      "target item observations",
      "family fits",
      "composite local target fit",
      "failed item lineage",
      "repair route selections",
      "candidate outcomes after external application"
    ],
    "DEFERRED_SEMANTIC_INPUTS[]": [
      "whether a specific asymmetric target is desirable",
      "whether candidate application improves task outcome",
      "cross-profile preference",
      "final layout selection"
    ],
    "HUMAN_FEEDBACK_HOOKS[]": [
      "target band correction",
      "family weight correction",
      "repair route approval",
      "candidate rejection reason"
    ],
    "CONFLICT_PRIORITY_ASSUMPTIONS[]": [
      "explicit profile declarations outrank implementation heuristics; conflicting exact declarations yield N_A rather than averaging"
    ],
    "LAB_HOOKS[]": [
      "perceived asymmetric balance versus centroid displacement",
      "moment-ratio perception",
      "regional mass asymmetry tolerance",
      "counterweight compensation perception"
    ]
  },
  "topic22ProgressAfterThisModule": "5/5 local",
  "next_step": "TOPIC22_CLOSING_AUDIT_SEPARATE_STEP",
  "topic23_started": false,
  "publication": "NOT_VERIFIED"
}